It
is truly wonderful in how many ways this doctrine(of the Atonement) is
taught, assumed, and implied in the Bible. It is expressed or implied upon
nearly every page of divine inspiration.
I present
several further reasons why an atonement in the case of the inhabitants
of this world was preferable to punishment, or to the execution of the
divine law. Several reasons have already been assigned, to which I will
add the following, some of which are plainly revealed in the Bible; others
are plainly inferrible from the very nature of the case.
(1.)
God's great and disinterested love to sinners themselves was a prime reason
for the atonement.
"For
God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever
believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life."
-John
3:16 -The New Testament(KJV)
(2.)His
great love to the universe at large must have been another reason, inasmuch
as it is impossible that the atonement should not exert an amazing influence
over moral beings, in whatever world they might exist, and where the fact
of atonement should be known.
(3.)Another
reason for substituting the sufferings of Christ in the place of the eternal
damnation of sinners is, that an infinite amount of suffering might be
prevented. The relation of Christ to the universe rendered his sufferings
so infinitely valuable and influential, and his great love to his subjects
on the other, that an infinitely less amount of suffering in him than must
have been inflicted on sinners, would be equally, and no doubt vastly more,
influential in supporting the government of God than the execution of the
law upon them would have been. Be it borne in mind, that Christ was the
lawgiver, and his suffering in behalf of sinners is to be regarded as the
lawgiver and executive magistrate suffering in the behalf and stead of
a rebellious province of his empire. As a governmental expedient it is
easy to see the great value of such a substitute; that on the one hand
it fully envinced the determination of the ruler not to yield the authority
of his law, and on the other, to evince his great and disinterested love
for his rebellious subjects.
(4.)
By this substitution, an immense good might be gained, the eternal happiness
of all that can be reclaimed from sin, together with all the augmented
happiness of those who have never sinned, that must result from this glorious
revelation of God.
(5.)
Another reason for preferring the atonement to the punishment of sinners
must have been, that sin had afforded an opportunity for the highest manifestation
of virtue in God: the manifestation of forbearance, mercy, self-denial,
and suffering for enemies that were within his own power, and for those
from whom he could expect no equivalent in return.
It
is impossible to conceive of a higher order of virtues than are exhibited
in the atonement of Christ. It was vastly desirable that God should take
advantage of such an opportunity to exhibit his true character, and show
to the universe what was in his heart. The strength and stability of any
government must depend upon the estimation in which the sovereign is held
by his subjects. It was therefore indispensable, that God should improve
the opportunity, which sin had afforded, to manifest and make known his
true character, and thus secure the highest confidence of his subjects.
(6.)
In the atonement God consulted his own happiness and his own glory. To
deny himself for the salvation of sinners, was a part of his own infinite
happiness, always intended by him, and therefore always enjoyed. This was
not selfishness in him, as his own well-being is of infinitely greater
value than that of all the universe besides; he ought so to regard and
treat it, because of its supreme and intrinsic value.
(7.)
The atonement would present to creatures the highest possible motives to
virtue. Example is the highest moral influence that can be exerted. If
God, or any other being, would make others benevolent, he must manifest
benevolence himself. If the benevolence manifested in the atonement does
not subdue the selfishness of sinners, their case is hopeless.
(8.)
The circumstances of his government rendered an atonement necessary; as
the execution of law was not, as a matter of fact, a sufficient preventive
of sin. The annihilation of the wicked would not answer the purposes of
government. A full revelation of mercy, blended with such an exhibition
of justice, was called for by the circumstances of the universe.
(9.)
To confirm holy beings. Nothing could be more highly calculated to establish
and confirm the confidence, love, and obedience of holy beings, than this
disinterested manifestation of love to sinners and rebels.
(10.)
To confound his enemies. How could anything be more directly calculated
to silence all cavils, and to shut every mouth, and forever close up all
opposing lips, than such an exhibition of love and willingness to make
sacrifices for sinners?
(11.)
The fact, that the execution of the law of God on rebel angels had not
arrested, and could not arrest, the progress of rebellion in the universe,
proves that something more needed to be done, in support of the authority
of law, than would be done in the execution of its penalty upon rebels.
While the execution of law may have a strong tendency to prevent the beginning
of rebellion among loyal subjects, and to restrain rebels themselves; yet
penal inflictions do not, in fact, subdue the heart, under any government,
whether human or divine.
As
a matter of fact, the law was only exasperating rebels, without confirming
holy beings. Paul(the apostle)affirmed, that the action of the law upon
his own mind, while in impenitence, was to beget in him all manner of concupiscence.
One grand reason for giving the law was, to develop the nature of sin,
and to show that the carnal mind is not subject to the law of God, neither
indeed can be. The law was therefore given that the offence might abound,
that thereby it might be demonstrated, that without an atonement there
could be no salvation for rebels under the government of God.
(12.)
The nature, degree, and execution of the penalty of the law, made the holiness
and the justice of God so prominent, as to absorb too much of public attention
to be safe. Those features of his character were so fully revealed, by
the execution of his law upon the rebel angels, that to have pursued the
same course with the inhabitants of this world, without the offer of mercy,
might have had, and doubtless would have had, an injurious influence upon
the universe, by creating more of fear than of love to God and his government.
Hence, a fuller revelation of the love and compassion of God was necessary,
to guard against the influence of slavish fear.
His
taking human nature, and obeying unto death, under such circumstances,
constituted a good reason for our being treated as righteous. It is a common
practice in human governments, and one that is founded in the nature and
laws of mind, to reward distinguished public service by conferring favors
on the children of those who have rendered this service, and treating them
as if they had rendered it themselves. This is both benevolent and wise.
Its governmental importance, its wisdom and excellent influence, have been
most abundantly attested in the experience of nations. As a governmental
transaction, this same principle prevails, and for the same reason, under
the government of God. All that are Christ's children and belong to him,
are received for his sake, treated with favor, and the rewards of the righteous
are bestowed upon them for his sake. And the public service which he as
rendered to the universe, by laying down his life for the support of the
divine government, has rendered it eminently wise, that all who are united
to him by faith should be treated as righteous for his sake.
He
made the atonement for the benefit of the universe. All holy beings are,
and must be, benefited by it, from its very nature, as it gives them a
higher knowledge of God than ever they had before, or ever could have gained
in any other way. The atonement is the greatest work that he could have
wrought for them, the most blessed and excellent, and benevolent thing
he could have done for them. For this reason, angels are described as desiring
to look into the atonement. The inhabitants of heaven are represented as
being deeply interested in the work of atonement, and those displays of
the character of God that are made in it. The atonement is then no doubt
one of the greatest blessings that ever God conferred upon the universe
of holy beings.